It seems to me as only the negative reviews have been posted so far, a little bias I think.
First of all let's stop comparing it to battlefield... it is not that game and was never meant to be. People's frustration over Battlefield 3 and 4 is making them jump to conclusions about other DICE/ EA games.
Yes it's hard not to be drawn into the beauty of the game! It looks and sounds fantastic and any star wars fan would be impressed. In terms of game play there are a few weapon/team balancing tweaks needed, but on the whole I found it enjoyable.
If I want a highly tactical game I would play ArmA or even CS: GO competitive. But if I want some faster paced fun where no one cares if they win or lose and it's more about having a laugh with friends, then this is the sort of game I'd play.
Remember this BETA is limited to 2 maps and 2 modes (1 map per a mode), the AT-AT map is a decent size and is more tactical and the Drop Pod mode is more like a COD run and gun game. There are many more modes in the full release and more maps to explore.
Now the big question: WOULD I BUY IT? Yes I would as the game is good fun, however there would be a few conditions:
- I'd have to watch some game play of the other game modes.
- I would have to be confident friend would get is as well.
- the teams would have to be balanced.